Our Scoring Methodology
Every tier score, price metric, and data point on ShilajitPrice.com is calculated using a transparent, reproducible methodology. Here's exactly how it works.
Tier Score System
S-Tier — Best in Class
Full third-party COA published publicly, 80%+ verified fulvic acid, all four heavy metals tested and passing, known source altitude, cold-process or traditional purification, free shipping, and money-back guarantee. These are the only products we actively recommend purchasing.
A-Tier — High Quality
Third-party tested with COA available, good purity score (7–8/10), heavy metals tested, known sourcing. May lack one or two S-tier criteria (e.g., slightly higher price per gram, or fulvic acid between 60–79%).
B-Tier — Acceptable
Some lab testing disclosed but limited COA transparency. Decent purity (5–6/10). Sourcing partially disclosed. Fine for budget buyers who want some testing confidence but cannot afford premium products.
C-Tier — Below Average
Minimal testing disclosure. COA not publicly available or unclear. Purity score 3–4/10. May list 'tested' claims without supporting documentation. Proceed with caution.
D-Tier — Not Recommended
No COA, no third-party testing evidence, unclear sourcing, and/or significant negative indicators in the product listing. We include these for comparison purposes only — we do not recommend purchasing D-tier products.
What Goes Into Each Score
Tier assignment is based on a weighted composite of five factors. Products must genuinely earn their tier — affiliate relationships have zero influence on placement.
| Factor | Weight | How We Measure It |
|---|---|---|
| COA Availability | 30% | Is a Certificate of Analysis publicly available from a named third-party lab? Is it current? Is it accessible directly from the brand's website? |
| Purity Score | 25% | Based on verified fulvic acid %, presence of trace minerals, absence of fillers, and overall lab-confirmed potency. Unverified brand claims receive a reduced score. |
| Heavy Metals Testing | 20% | All four metals (Lead, Mercury, Arsenic, Cadmium) must be tested by a third party and pass FDA action level thresholds. Missing or untested panels reduce score significantly. |
| Sourcing Transparency | 15% | Is the source location (e.g. Himalayas, Altai) disclosed? Is the altitude stated? Is the purification method described? Vague 'Himalayan origin' claims without specifics receive partial credit. |
| Price & Value | 10% | Price per gram and cost per serving are calculated and compared across the database. Products with exceptional value within their purity tier receive a small score boost. |
How Key Metrics Are Calculated
Price Per Gram
priceUsd ÷ weightGrams
e.g. $36.99 ÷ 30g = $1.23/g (Black Lotus Resin)
This is the most useful metric for comparing raw shilajit products. Lower is better, but only if purity is equivalent. A $0.50/g product with no COA is not better value than a $1.23/g product with full lab verification.
Cost Per Serving
priceUsd ÷ servingsPerContainer
e.g. $36.99 ÷ 100 servings = $0.37/serving
More useful for daily-use comparison. Serving size varies significantly between products — always check the serving size when comparing cost per serving.
Purity Score (1–10)
Composite score from: COA data + fulvic acid % + heavy metals + sourcing
e.g. Black Lotus: 10/10 — Full COA, 85% FA, all metals pass, Himalayan 16,000ft
This is an editorial score based on publicly verifiable data. It is not a measure of the product's health effects. We are evaluating transparency and documented quality, not making medical claims.
How We Verify COA Claims
Find the official brand website
We navigate to the brand's own domain — not reseller pages.
Locate the COA or lab page
We look for dedicated lab analysis pages, "certificate of analysis" links, or downloadable PDFs from the brand's site.
Verify the lab name is disclosed
A COA from an anonymous "third-party lab" gets partial credit. A named, accredited lab gets full credit.
Check the data matches marketing claims
If a brand claims 85% fulvic acid in marketing copy, their COA must support it. Unsupported claims reduce the purity score.
Record only what is publicly verifiable
We never display lab numbers we cannot verify from a public source. "Not Available" is always shown honestly.
How Reviews Are Sourced & Attributed
Important: ShilajitPrice.com does not sell products and cannot verify purchases. We display only reviews sourced from Amazon, brand websites, and Reddit, with full attribution to the original source. We do not create or fabricate reviews.
Brand COA Pages
Official Certificate of Analysis pages linked directly from brand websites. We only use lab numbers that appear on the brand's own published COA — never from marketing copy.
Amazon Product Listings
Price, review count, and star rating sourced from Amazon product pages. We note when COA is referenced on the listing vs. not present.
Brand Review Pages
Customer reviews sourced from brand websites with clear attribution. We do not alter review text and display reviewer name/initial as published.
Prices
Prices verified at the date noted on each product card. Prices change — always confirm on the retailer's site before purchasing.
Affiliate Relationships & Editorial Independence
ShilajitPrice.com has affiliate partnerships with Black Lotus Shilajit and Pure Himalayan Shilajit. When you purchase through our affiliate links, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Affiliate relationships do not influence tier scores, rankings, or any data point on this site. These brands are featured because their published lab data earned them S-tier scores — not because of our commercial relationship with them.
If a brand with an affiliate partnership produced poor lab results, they would receive a lower tier score. We also include Amazon products and competitor brands with no affiliate relationship because comprehensive comparison is more useful to readers than cherry-picking.